Melodic minor in practice

Use the raised sixth and seventh going up and natural minor going down.

Different up and down

Going up, melodic minor raises two degrees: VI and VII. Going down the raised notes return to normal, and natural minor sounds.

In A minor: up A, B, C, D, E, F♯, G♯, A; down A, G, F, E, D, C, B, A.

A melodic minor, up and down

Practice: Which minor? (1)

Practice: What changes?

Why two degrees

In harmonic minor there is an augmented second between degrees VI and VII. In a melody this step sounds harsh and "oriental". Raising degree VI smooths it to a whole tone while keeping the leading note.

Going down the leading note is not needed: the melody is not reaching up to the tonic, so the raised notes are dropped. In practice that is how it is written: a line rising to the tonic uses the raised degrees; a line falling from the tonic does not.

A harmonic minor: E – F – G♯ – A

A melodic minor: E – F♯ – G♯ – A

Melodic minor is recognised by its upper half: going up, it is the same as in major. The lower half of the scale is minor, with a minor third.

Practice: Which minor? (2)

Practice: Which minor? (3)

Practice: Three minors by ear